The room looks perfect. The dates work. You check the price on one booking site: $185 a night.
Then you look somewhere else.
$162.
The hotel's own website says $179.
You log into a membership platform and suddenly the same hotel appears at yet another price.
Same hotel. Same night. Same room.
So what exactly is going on?
The answer reveals something most travellers rarely think about: a hotel room doesn't really have one price.
It has a distribution system.
The Room Is the Same. The Route to It Isn't.
When you buy a hotel room, you're not necessarily buying it directly from the hotel.
Hotels distribute their rooms through multiple channels. These can include their own websites, online travel agencies, traditional travel agents, wholesalers, tour operators, corporate travel programs, loyalty schemes and private membership platforms.
Each route can operate under different commercial arrangements.
That means two travellers staying in identical rooms on the same night may have reached those rooms through completely different parts of the travel-distribution system — and paid different prices along the way.
Hotels Don't Simply Set a Price and Leave It There
Hotel pricing has become remarkably sophisticated.
A property might have a standard flexible rate, a cheaper non-refundable rate, a breakfast-inclusive rate, a mobile-only offer, a loyalty rate, a corporate rate, a last-minute promotion or a rate available only to members of a particular group.
Prices can also change according to demand.
If a conference suddenly fills a city, remaining rooms may become more expensive. If occupancy is weaker than expected, prices can move in the opposite direction.
Hotels therefore aren't selling rooms in quite the same way a shop sells a television with a price tag attached.
They're selling perishable inventory.
Tonight's empty hotel room cannot be put back on the shelf and sold tomorrow. Once the night passes, its potential revenue disappears forever.
That creates an enormous incentive to manage both price and distribution carefully.
Then Come the Booking Platforms
Online travel agencies transformed hotel distribution by giving properties access to enormous global audiences.
For a small hotel in Cape Town, Bangkok or Zanzibar, appearing on a major booking platform can put the property in front of travellers thousands of kilometres away who may never have discovered it independently.
That reach has value.
The platforms generally make money when bookings occur, which means distribution itself becomes part of the economics of the room.
This is where things become interesting.
A hotel isn't simply asking:
How much is this room worth tonight?
It is also considering:
Through which channel is this room being sold?
Different channels can have different costs, rules, audiences and pricing arrangements.
Why Doesn't Every Website Just Show the Same Price?
Sometimes they do.
The hotel industry has long used arrangements commonly described as rate parity, under which equivalent publicly available rooms may be offered at the same price across specified distribution channels.
But the global picture is not as simple as “every website must display the same rate.”
Parity rules and contractual arrangements differ between markets, and the regulatory environment has changed significantly over the years. Hotels can also operate multiple rate plans, while some offers are restricted to particular groups rather than being publicly available to everyone.
And there is another complication:
Two prices that look different aren't necessarily offering exactly the same thing.
One might include breakfast.
Another might be non-refundable.
One may allow cancellation until the day before arrival.
Another may require payment immediately.
One might include taxes in the displayed figure while another adds certain charges later.
The headline number isn't always the true comparison.
The Importance of Member Rates
This is where private pricing becomes particularly interesting.
A publicly advertised hotel rate is visible to everyone.
A member rate, by contrast, may only become visible after a traveller logs into an eligible program or platform.
Closed-user or membership pricing is an established part of modern hotel distribution. The principle is straightforward: a rate doesn't necessarily have to be offered to the entire public simply because it can be offered to a defined group of customers.
Hotels and travel suppliers may therefore participate in distribution arrangements that aren't immediately visible when somebody performs an ordinary public search.
This helps explain one of the more confusing experiences in travel shopping:
You search Google and see broadly similar prices everywhere — and then encounter a materially different price after entering a private booking environment.
It isn't necessarily the hotel suddenly changing the room.
You may simply have entered a different distribution channel.
Wholesalers Add Another Layer
There is an even less visible part of the hotel business.
Hotels can supply inventory through wholesalers and other intermediaries that distribute accommodation onward through travel companies and booking systems.
That means the website where you eventually see a hotel room may not necessarily have obtained that inventory directly from the hotel itself.
Modern hotel distribution can contain several layers between the property and the person eventually sleeping in the bed.
To the traveller, however, all of this complexity is compressed into a deceptively simple button:
BOOK NOW.
Behind that button can sit an entire commercial ecosystem.
Why Booking Direct Isn't Automatically Cheapest
You've probably heard the advice:
Always book directly with the hotel.
Sometimes that's excellent advice.
Hotels have strong reasons to encourage direct bookings, including the ability to develop a direct relationship with the guest and avoid some third-party distribution costs.
They may offer incentives such as complimentary breakfast, upgrades, flexible cancellation or loyalty points.
But “direct is always cheapest” is too simplistic.
A promotional offer, private member rate, wholesale arrangement or platform-specific discount can sometimes produce a lower price elsewhere.
Equally, the cheapest-looking third-party rate isn't automatically the best deal once cancellation terms, taxes, breakfast, payment conditions and other benefits are considered.
The intelligent approach isn't loyalty to one booking method.
It's comparison.
Compare the Stay, Not Just the Number
Before booking, compare like with like.
Check whether you're looking at precisely the same room category.
Check the cancellation terms.
Check whether breakfast is included.
Check whether taxes and fees have already been added.
Check payment conditions.
And, increasingly, check whether you have access to a member or private rate that isn't displayed publicly.
A $150 room with breakfast and free cancellation may be better value than a $140 room without either.
The lowest number on the screen isn't necessarily the lowest cost of the stay.
Hotel Booking Has Become a Distribution Business
This is the larger story.
The internet was supposed to make travel pricing radically transparent.
In one sense, it did.
A traveller can compare hundreds of hotels in seconds — something that would have been almost unimaginable before online travel became mainstream.
But the internet also created an enormous new industry devoted to organising, distributing, marketing and monetising hotel inventory.
The hotel owns the room.
But increasingly, enormous economic value is created by whoever connects that room with the traveller.
That helps explain how some of the world's most powerful travel companies have been built without owning the hotels being booked through their platforms.
And it also explains why new travel-distribution models continue to emerge.
The next time you find the same hotel room at three different prices, don't assume somebody has made a mistake.
You may simply be looking through three different windows into the same global travel marketplace.
— Blockbuster Articles
Recommended next read:
Viago: A Structural Review of an Alternative Distribution Model
Private travel membership represents another approach to the distribution question explored above. This structural review examines the Viago model, how it differs from conventional online travel distribution, and the role members play within its ecosystem.
No comments:
Post a Comment